|

RESULTATS
DU CONGRES
Résultats
sur la valeur non-matérielle des aires protégées
En cours
de traduction, désolés pour les inconvénients
OUTPUTS
OF THE CONGRESS
Non-Material
Values of Protected Areas
Summary
The Full Value of Parks
The Sacred dimension of PAs, a Special Ceremony
Preliminary Guidelines on the Management
of Sacred Natural Sites
Proceedings of the WPC Technical Sessions
on Cultural Support for PAs
Pre-Feasibility Study of a System of Pas
Associated with the Great Inca Highland Road
Summary
The WCPA's Task Force
on Non-Material Values will produce 5 major outputs
for the World Parks Congress:
back to
top
"The Full Value of Parks"
As stated on the jacket
of the book: "The Full Value of Parks" is
the first comprehensive look at the values associated with parks
and other kinds of protected areas. Parks are essential to the tourism
industry, and the economic benefits of protected areas are undeniably
important. Yet the reasons why people care deeply about them usually
have little or nothing to do with money. Instead, people value parks
as settings of breathtaking beauty, as venues of scientific inquiry,
as destinations for much-needed recreation, as sacred sanctuaries
and places of spiritual self-discovery-even as places where one
can go to heal a wounded psyche.
The profound attachments
that people feel to the world's great natural areas and cultural
sites arise from an incredibly diverse, complex, and sometimes conflicting
array of values. After a thorough overview of the values found in
parks, the unique challenges of managing parks to accommodate differing
viewpoints are surveyed in this groundbreaking book. Drawing on
insights from a broad group of international experts, and offering
examples from Siberia to tropical Africa, from the Andes to the
Australian outback, The Full Value of Parks is an engaging
and lucid exploration of the entire range of benefits and values
of protected areas-from economics to the intangible."
The book was edited by
David Harmon and Allen Putney. The authors of the volume
are Mercedes Otegui Acha, Steven A. Acker, Gérman I. Andrade,
Angu Kenneth Angu, Jonathan I. Barnes, Bradley W. Barr, Vladimir
Boreyko, Eduardo Crespo de Nogueira, Natalia Danilina, Gary E. Davis,
Rod Ehler, Anthony J. English, Alan Ewert, Joel Geffen, David M.
Graber, Adrienne Hall, David Harmon, Terence Hay-Edie, Steven J.
Hollenhorst, Bayie Kamanda, Ashish Kothari, Ellen Lee, Consuelo
Martinez Flores, Leo McAvoy, Jean-Claude Nguinguiri, Neema Pathak,
Allen D. Putney, P. S. Ramakrishnan, Holmes Rolston III, Mechtild
Rössler, Keith C. Russell, Fausto O. Sarmiento, Thomas Schaaf,
John Shultis, Bron Taylor, Michael J. Tranel, and Peter Wiley.
back to
top
The
Sacred Dimension of Protected Areas, a Special Ceremony
The Special Ceremony
on the Sacred Dimension of Protected Areas will be presented at
the WPC on the night of September
9 from 20:15 to 21:30.
The purpose of the ceremony
is to convey the importance of the sacred dimension of protected
areas, no so much through the mind as through the heart and soul.
The ceremony will be composed of music, videos, and presentations
by key personalities. The entire event will be videotaped and placed
on CDs for distribution later in the Congress.
Invitation
to the Special Ceremony // "In
the Light of Reverence" Film presentation's Flyer
back to
top
Preliminary Guidelines on the Management of Sacred Natural Sites
IUCN and UNESCO
have sponsored workshops and case studies that have provided initial
insights on the management of sacred natural sites. Based on this
work, preliminary guidelines are being pulled together as the beginning
point for discussions on the topic during technical sessions at
the WPC. A revised draft will be compiled after the Congress, drawing
on the inputs received at the Congress, and distributed through
the IUCN and UNESCO networks. The guidelines will cover sacred natural
sites situated within established protected as, as well as those
that are outside of the current protected area system.
back to
top
Proceedings of the WPC Technical Sessions on Cultural Support for
Protected Areas
Overview /
Part 1: Non material values of PAs / Part
2 : Sacred Natural Sites
The Technical Session
on Cultural Support for Protected Areas will provide an opportunity
for a series of presentations and discussions among those working
on this theme in protected areas around the world. These sessions
will be organized as follows:
Overview
This session will include:
Part 1: Non-material values of protected areas, including spiritual
values
(September 11, and September 12 AM)
Theme / Goals
/ Schedule
Theme:
An improved understanding
of the non-material values of protected areas throughout the world
by managers, policy makers, and the public is essential to the long-term
survival of these special places.
Improved understanding
of non-material values will lead to:
| 1.
|
Better
decisions on future designations and management of parks and
protected areas to widen the scope of the concept of "Protected
Area" in the biocultural context. |
| 2.
|
More
effective conflict resolution strategies where non-material
values are involved. |
| 3.
|
Management
and policy actions that take into account the relationships
between natural and cultural values. |
| 4.
|
A greater
role of parks and protected areas in bringing people into contact
with nature and stimulating reflection on individual and societal
relationships to nature, and provide opportunities for one to
be in harmony with oneself and with others. |
Goals:
| 1.
|
Provide
strategies for park and protected area managers to resolve conflicts
among values, in order to protect non-material values, by reviewing
case studies from around the world. |
| 2. |
Evaluate
recent experiences, and high priority needs for the future,
regarding designation of parks and other areas to protect specific
non-material values, with greater public understanding and involvement
(local communities, visitors, and the wider public). |
| 3.
|
Develop
specific recommendations flowing from 1-2 above to address:
" Future directions for the Task Force on Non-Material
Values. |
| |
Increased public education
and awareness especially where most needed: taking advantage
of new opportunities to develop holistic people-nature relationships
|
| |
Effectively working
within a wide variety of political processes |
| |
Providing opportunities
for full and meaningful involvement of indigenous peoples, local
populations, traditional peoples, and modern groups in preservation
of non-material values |
| |
Develop mechanisms
to gain recognition of sacred natural sites for biodiversity
conservation. |
Schedule:
September
11: Panel discussions, with presentations,
on #1-2 above
September 12, AM: Facilitated
workshop discussion to develop recommendations (#3 above)
| September
11 |
| 11:00-12:30
- |
Dave
Harmon, facilitator; individual presentations followed
by a discussion among Panel Members. |
|
1.
Overview, Dave Harmon - (5 minutes) |
|
2.
Building cultural support through environmental education,
Tiahoga Ruge, Mexico - (20 minutes) |
|
3.
Building cultural support through development of a network
of protected areas associated with an under-utilized Andean
archaeological treasure, the Great Inca Highland Road, Ricardo
Espinosa and Miriam Torres, Peru - (20 minutes) |
|
4.
Building cultural support by resolving conflicts among competing
values, Mike Tranel, USA - (20 minutes) |
|
5.
Discussion among Panel Members - (25 minutes) |
| 14:00-15:30
- |
Dave
Harmon, facilitator; individual presentations followed
by discussion among the Panel Members. |
|
1.
Overview, Dave Harmon - (5 minutes) |
|
2.
New ways of involving local, indigenous, and traditional populations
in protecting and managing non-material values, Mercedes Otegui,
Mexico - (20 minutes) |
|
3.
Protecting nature when nature is part of culture. Gonzalo
Oviedo, IUCN - (20 minutes) |
| |
4.
Concepts for a Peace Park in Argentina and Chile that expands
the concept (presenter to be determined) - (20 minutes) |
| |
5.
Discussion among Panel Members - (25 minutes) |
| September
12 |
|
8:00-9:30
-
|
The
purpose is to develop specific recommendations to address the
following issues. |
| |
1.
Programs needed to fully integrate non-material values into
the management of PAs. |
| |
2.
Providing opportunities for full and meaningful involvement
of indigenous and traditional peoples, faith groups, local populations,
and interest groups concerned with non-material values while
working within a wide variety of political processes. |
| |
3.
Expanding the concept of Peace Parks to include a focus
on internal peace and harmony for the individual; peace between,
communities, cultures and generations; peace between human society
and the environment; and peace among nations. |
| These
questions will be answered through facilitated discussions in
work groups, the number and sizing depending on the number of
participants. Each group will be challenged to come up with
an action plan for one of the three topics above. Facilitators
from the Task Force will assist each work group. |
|
10:00-12:30
-
|
Each
of the groups will have 30 minutes to present their action plan
and discuss it with the wider group. If necessary, ad hoc Working
Groups will be set up to explore critical issues in more detail. |
Part
2: Sacred Natural Sites
(September 12pm, and September 13)
Theme / Goals
/ Schedule
Themes:
Exploration, in collaboration
with representatives of indigenous peoples, faith groups, and the
wider conservation community:
| 1.
|
Role
of sacred natural sites (SNS) of indigenous peoples, faith groups,
and the wider community as protected areas. |
| 2.
|
Potential
contribution of SNS to an expansion of protected area networks
worldwide. |
| 3.
|
Appropriate
policies, laws and technical tools for the long-term protection,
effective management and restoration of SNS. |
| 4.
|
Mobilising
public support for SNS. |
Goals
| 1.
|
To
raise awareness of SNS as protected areas within the international
conservation
community. |
| 2. |
To open
discussion on key issues and problems associated with SNS within
existing protected areas, and the inclusion of new areas in
protected area systems. |
| 3.
|
To
formulate policy recommendations and steps forward, in collaboration
with different faith and cultural groups. |
Schedule
September
12, PM: Introductory Panel Presentations and Case Studies
September 13, AM: Sacred Natural Sites Poster Session
and Discussion of guidelines
| September
12pm |
|
14:00-15:30
-
|
PM:
Miriam Torres, facilitator |
|
1.
Briefing on outcomes from the Kunming, China Workshop on
Sacred Natural Sites, Prof. Pei Sengji - (20 minutes) |
|
2.
Case studies on SNSs, 15 minutes each (60 minutes) |
|
Yogesh
Gokale, India |
|
Maria
Teresa Amaya, Colombia |
|
Mercedes
Otegui, Maurilio de la Cruz, and Antonio Robles, Mexico |
|
Edwin
Bernbaum, US |
|
3. Questions
-
(10 minutes) |
|
16:00-17:30
-
|
1.
Case Studies on SNSs, 15 minutes each (90 minutes) |
|
|
Zvidzai
Cidhakwa, Zimbabwe |
| |
Pei
Shengji, China |
| |
Hanta
Rabetaliana or Peter Schachermann, Madagascar |
| |
Mikkhail
Todishev, Russia |
|
Edmund
Barrow, Kenya |
| |
Estuardo
Secaira, Guatemala |
| September
13 |
|
9:00-10:30
-
|
Miriam
Torres, Facilitator |
| |
1.
Case Studies - 15 minutes each (90 minutes) |
| |
Alejandro
Argumedo, Peru |
| |
Robert
Moseley, China |
| |
Pema
Bhutia, Representative of the community of Rathong Chu, India |
| |
Mark
Enfield and Arthur Mugisha, Kenya |
| |
2.
Poster session to give participants a chance to talk in
more depth with the 14
case study authors - (30 minutes) |
|
11:00-12:30
-
|
Mechtild
Rossler, Facilitator |
| |
1.
Using World Heritage to link Nature and Culture, Mechtild
Rossler, UNESCO - (20 minutes) |
| |
2.
Questions on World Heritage - (10 minutes) |
| |
3.
Introduction of preliminary technical guidelines for managing
sacred natural sites,
Allen Putney and Mechtild Rossler- (20 minutes) |
| |
4.
Facilitated discussion of the proposed technical guidelines
on SNS management
- (40 minutes) |
|
14:00-15:30
-
|
Allen
Putney and Gonzalo Oviedo, Facilitators |
| |
1.
Future directions for the Task Force on Non-Material Values
- (40 minutes) |
| |
2.
A Multi-Institutional Sacred Natural Sites Initiative (Gonzalo
Oviedo) - (20 minutes) |
| |
3.
Discussion of Sacred Natural Sites Initiative - (30
minutes) |
| After
the Congress, proceedings of the Technical Session will be compiled
and posted on the WCPA website. |
back to
top
Pre-Feasibility Study of a System of Protected Areas Associated
with the Great Inca Highland Road
Sacred natural sites
can be large areas, such as those associated with sacred mountains,
or smaller ones, such as those associated with sacred groves, caves,
springs or rock formations. In other cases, whole landscapes are
considered sacred, such as the high mountain landscapes of the Andes
that parallel the west coast of South America. The Great Inca Highland
Road runs 6,000 km. along the spine of the Andes. It was the central
longitudinal route that connected a much larger road system built
by Pre-Colombian Andean societies, and which was improved upon and
completed during the reign of the Inca Empire. It traverses these
sacred landscapes and has the potential to bring together once again
the high mountain Andean societies of the countries of Ecuador,
Peru, Bolivia, Chile and Argentina.
Until recently, this
archaeological treasure had fallen into abandon and was largely
forgotten. This changed when Peruvian Ricardo Espinosa hiked about
4,000 kms. of the Great Road from Quito, Ecuador to La Paz, Bolivia.
During his journey, he mapped the Road's location, took over 6,000
photographs, and published a book.
For many, the Great Inca
Highland Road is a sacred road, and as such it provides an interesting
opportunity to develop a network of protected areas associated with
this monument to Andean ingenuity and capacity, and to their attachment
to the Pachamama, or Mother Earth. It also provides an opportunity
to build this network with and through Andean Communities along
its route, focusing on the reintegration of Andean culture, and
the recognition of their cosmology, their view of people's place
in the Universe, their understanding of the sacred.
This Great Road has an
equally great potential for community-based ecotourism. Not only
would some of the poorest communities in South America have an opportunity
for economic development while maintaining and building on the roots
of their culture. These communities could offer an unparalleled
tourism product built on respect for local culture and traditions,
and offering the visitor the chance to be a pilgrim, to make an
outward journey leading to inward growth, understanding and harmony,
and all of this through some of the most spectacular high mountain
scenery in the world.
The results of
the Pre-Feasibility study will be presented at the WPC through
a multi-media presentation accompanied by a technical report and
a glossy Executive Summary. The presentation will focus on the following
topics:
| 1.
Introduction |
|
a.
|
Verbal
introduction by Lead Speaker |
|
|
Welcome to event |
|
|
Purpose and contents of the presentation |
|
|
Presentation of team |
|
|
Strategic themes - the sacred dimension, Andean re-integration,
protected areas |
|
b.
|
Video
Presentation |
|
|
15-20 minutes |
|
|
scenes from Ecuador, Perú, Bolivia, Chile and Argentina |
|
|
orientation maps of Inca road system and the Great Inca Highland
Road , eco-regions it transverses, existing protected areas,
and associated natural and cultural resources |
|
2.
Findings of Pre-Feasibility Study
|
|
a.
|
a.
Status of the Great Inca Highland Road (GIHR), and associated
natural and cultural resources |
|
|
Location |
|
|
State of preservation |
|
|
Archaeological setting |
|
|
Current uses |
|
|
Ethnic and linguistic groups |
|
|
Socio-economic profiles (map of extreme poverty) |
|
|
Communities along the route |
|
|
Eco-regions it traverses |
|
|
Existing protected areas along the route |
|
|
Important natural features along the route |
|
|
Sacred sites |
|
|
Conservation potential, including biological corridors |
|
|
Importance for agro-biodiversity |
|
b.
|
The
Sacred Dimension |
|
|
A road passing through a sacred landscape or, a road built to
honor the sacred? |
|
|
Perceptions of the sacred dimension |
|
|
Forging identity within diversity |
|
|
Developing a project that honors the sacred dimension, especially
Andean cosmology |
|
c.
|
Sustainable
Development |
|
|
Starting
from the standpoint of the 3 strategic themes - the sacred dimension,
Andean re-integration, protected areas |
|
|
Pachamama
(the sacred dimension) > processes (traditional knowledge,
tourism, protected areas) > result (re-integration) >
new dynamic leading to a sustainable development that honors
the sacred. |
|
d.
|
Tourism
Potential |
|
|
Concepts for a tourism respectful of the local cultures and
their understanding of the Universe, community based tourism. |
|
|
Modes of use that revive the traditional use of the GRI (tambos,
llamas, complementarities, reciprocity) |
|
|
Building a very special tourism product that is a dialog with
the landscape, transformative experience, Andean cosmology,
and the Andean notion of reciprocity. |
|
e.
|
Institutional
Considerations |
|
|
A network that accesses capacities within communities, technical
institutions, governments, private enterprise, NGOs, the sacred,
and funding. |
|
|
A coordinating entity |
| |
A leading Andean patron |
| 3.
Follow-up Priorities |
|
a.
|
Regional
priorities |
|
|
Development and coordination of the network |
|
|
Standards for tourism development |
|
|
Cultural exchange |
|
|
Diffusion of concepts and priorities |
|
b
|
National
priorities (to be determined in national workshops) |
| 4.
Project Profiles |
| 5.
Conclusion |
After the conclusion
of the presentation, and a question and answer period, a Donor's
Round Table will be held to mobilize finance for priority projects
for development of a network of protected areas associated with
the Great Inca Highland Road,
back
to top
|
 |
|